Median-Sale-Price Miracles: Cities Where Homes Sell for Surprisingly High Prices

In this analysis, we explore the top cities where homes sell for unexpectedly high prices. Our data reveals that cities like Sturgis, South Dakota, have a median sale price of $369,375,000, with homes staying on the market for 200 days.

Let's compare this to Indian Creek, Florida, which has a median price of $79,000,000, and homes sell for this price in just 141 days. This represents a significant difference of $290,375,000 in median price and 59 days in days on market.

Another city worth noting is Jupiter Island, Florida, where the median sale price is $16,000,000, and homes sell for this price in 103 days. In comparison, Sagaponack, New York, has a median sale price of $15,500,000, and homes sell for this price in just 82 days.

Exploring the Data

Looking at the data, we can see that the median sale price is significantly higher in Sturgis, South Dakota, compared to other cities. In fact, the median sale price in Sturgis is over $290 million more than in Indian Creek, Florida.

Additionally, the days on market vary greatly between cities. While homes in Sturgis stay on the market for 200 days, homes in Sullivan's Island, South Carolina, sell in just 5 days.

Let's take a closer look at the data for each city:

City State Median Price Homes Sold Inventory Days on Market Sturgis South Dakota $369,375,000 200 days Indian Creek Florida $79,000,000 141 days Jupiter Island Florida $16,000,000 103 days Sagaponack New York $15,500,000 148 days Sullivan's Island South Carolina $13,500,000 130 days Hunts Point Washington $12,500,000 152 days Crystal Bay Nevada $11,800,000 190 days Watch Hill Rhode Island $11,750,000 1 2 182 days Fort Wingate New Mexico $11,000,000 1 N/A 515 days Mulford Colorado $10,750,000 143 days

Comparing Cities

When comparing the cities, we can see that Sturgis, South Dakota, has the highest median sale price, followed closely by Indian Creek, Florida. Jupiter Island, Florida, has a significantly lower median sale price but a shorter days on market.

For homebuyers looking for a quick sale, cities like Sullivan's Island, South Carolina, and Jupiter Island, Florida, may be good options. However, for those looking for a higher sale price, Sturgis, South Dakota, may be the way to go.

It's also worth noting that some cities, like Fort Wingate, New Mexico, have a much longer days on market, which may indicate a slower real estate market.

For more information on home sales analysis and cities where analysis, check out our related post, Home Sales Velocity: Unveiling the Hottest Markets Where Homes Sell Fastest.

Additionally, for more information on cities where median list prices are skyrocketing in 2025, check out our related post, Top 10 Booming U.S. Cities Where Median List Prices Are Skyrocketing in 2025.

Finally, for more information on cities with tight housing inventory, check out our related post, Supply Squeeze: Unveiling Cities with the Tightest Housing Inventory.