Cayuga, NY has safety grade D, a population of about 437, an overall crime rate near 19,451 per 100k as of 2026. For real estate investors, safety is only half the picture: pair these crime statistics with rental demand and returns to judge whether Cayuga, NY is a sound place to buy. See the investment overview for Cayuga, NY for median prices, rental yield and Pulse Score, or run the numbers in the ROI analyzer.
Cayuga, NY Crime Rate and Safety Report
Cayuga, NY crime snapshot: safety grade D, violent crime rate 101.00 per 1,000 residents, property crime rate 85.00 per 1,000 residents. Compare nearby zip codes, hotspots, and safety recommendations below.
Safety Score
D
High Risk
Violent Crime Rate
101.00
per 1000 residents
Safety Analysis & Recommendations
View DetailsOverall Assessment
Cayuga, NY demonstrates excellent safety with a A+ safety rating. The area maintains low crime rates and is considered very safe for residents and visitors.
Safety Recommendations
Given the higher rate of violent crimes (51.8% of total incidents), residents should prioritize personal safety measures, avoid walking alone at night, and stay informed about local safety alerts.
Trend Analysis
The relatively low crime count of 85 incidents suggests Cayuga maintains good community safety standards.
Comparison Insights
Cayuga demonstrates crime rates well below national averages, showcasing effective community safety initiatives.
Cayuga, NY Crime Analysis
Based on the provided crime data for the area with GEOID 16000US3613068, a detailed analysis reveals the following insights. The total count of reported crimes is 85. Property crime constitutes a significant portion, with a total count of 37 incidents. Within property crime, Larceny/Theft Offenses are the most prevalent, accounting for 20 incidents, followed by Destruction/Damage/Vandalism of Property with 13 incidents. Motor Vehicle Theft is relatively less frequent, with only 2 incidents, while Burglary/Breaking & Entering and Stolen Property Offenses each have 1 incident. Assault offenses are also a major concern, with a total count of 41 incidents. Robbery accounts for 3 incidents, while sex offenses are relatively low, with a total of 2 incidents, split evenly between Sex Offenses and Sex Offenses, Non-forcible. The "others" category includes Counterfeiting/Forgery and Fraud Offenses, each with 1 incident. To provide a comprehensive safety assessment, additional data is needed, including the city name, state name, population, median income, crime rate per 100k, safety score, safety grade, violent crime rate, property crime rate, crime map data, and zip codes data. Without this information, a complete safety profile cannot be generated.
Cayuga, NY crime map
Crime Map
Green markers indicate safer areas, red markers indicate high crime areas. Blue markers show the currently selected zip code.
Safest Zip Codes
High Crime Zip Codes
10152
0
Safety50.9
Per 1K51
Total Crimes10112
0
Safety43.5
Per 1K44
Total Crimes11252
0
Safety37.7
Per 1K38
Total Crimes14203
0
Safety34.1
Per 1K34
Total CrimesRelated analysis for Cayuga, NY
Explore related real estate, safety, and education data for Cayuga, NY.
Explore more locations near Cayuga, NY
Browse data for nearby cities and zip codes.
Nearby zip codes
FAQ about crime in Cayuga, NY
Crime rates are normalized per 1,000 residents based on reported incidents in FBI UCR and local agency feeds. We split incidents into violent, property, and other categories so you can see where the risk concentrates.
The “Safest Zip Codes” section above ranks nearby zip codes by safety score, while the “High Crime Zip Codes” section highlights areas with elevated reported crime in Cayuga, NY.
Crime data is refreshed on a rolling basis as updated reports are published by the FBI’s Crime Data Explorer and partnering agencies.
Combine this crime report with the market overview for Cayuga, NY and the school report linked in the “Related analysis” section to assess both safety and investment fundamentals.
Data sources & further reading
PulseReal’s analysis is built on top of these public, authoritative datasets.
Official UCR crime statistics by state and agency from the FBI.
Population, demographics, housing, and income data from the US Census Bureau.
Encyclopedic overview of the city, history, and notable landmarks.
Housing affordability, fair-market rents, and market reports from HUD.
Local unemployment and employment data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Bureau of Justice Statistics publications on US crime victimization.
Get Complete Insights or Analytics
Access comprehensive real estate data, crime analysis, short term rental data, and detailed zip code reports across the United States.
✓ Analyze real estate data ✓ Neighborhood safety ratings ✓ Detailed crime statistics
Disclaimer: All investment decisions involve risks, and the information provided by Pulsereal is for informational purposes only. We do not guarantee any specific outcomes, returns, or profitability. Users are encouraged to conduct their own due diligence and consult with a financial advisor or real estate professional before making any investment decisions. Pulsereal is not responsible for any losses or damages arising from the use of the platform or reliance on the provided information.
Copyright © 2026 Pulse Real LLC.